Blake Shelton and Trace Adkins have just released a duet, “Hell Right,” that seems to have a beef with “Old Town Road.” But is it a light-hearted, maybe even affectionate slam — or should anyone read culture-war significance into the two country stars expressing a preference for Hank Williams Jr. over Lil Nas X , the breakout sensation of the year?
The eyebrow-raising passage has Shelton singing, “Then the girl from the small town took off the âOld Town,â put on a little Hank Jr.,” followed by a clearly relieved Adkins intoning: “Thank God.”
To some listeners, thatâs just Shelton and Adkins pitting real country, as represented by Williams Jr., against fake country, in the form of Lil Nas X âs country-trap hybrid. Others have wondered about the optics of bringing up Lil Nas X, one of the few black stars in history to have a substantial hit with a country (or at least country-adjacent) song, in an unfavorable comparison to, of all people, Williams Jr., who for decades has been practically a poster boy for the Confederate flag and pro-Confederacy sentiments.
Maria Cecilia Suñe Ramos |
Related Top Music Industry LGBTQ Executives, Creators Debate Bias in the Biz, Hail Lil Nas X Camila Cabello, Shawn Mendes, Lil Nas X, J Balvin, More Join VMAs Lineup
Among those expressing concern over the juxtaposition was David Cantwell, a country music author and historian whose books include an acclaimed Merle Haggard biography (and who wrote about Hank Jr.âs complicated legacy for the New Yorker ). “On the new Blake Shelton single, saying âHell Rightâ to someone taking off âOld Town Roadâ and putting on something else is, in this moment, a dick move,” Cantwell tweeted. “OK, whatever. But taking off Lil Nas in favor of Hank Jr. will be predictably, understandably read as a racist dick move. WTF Blake?” Other country music journalists and observers chimed in in agreement with Cantwellâs take
A spokesperson for Shelton insists no disrespect toward Lil Nas X was intended in the new song: “Itâs absolutely not throwing any kind of shade at Lil Nas X at all. Blake says this literally has nothing to do with anything at all except how much the song is played. It could have been âAchy Breaky Heartâ or any other (overplayed) song.” Speaking of Billy Ray Cyrus, who did a duet with Lil Nas X on a remix of “Old Town Road”: “Blake talked to Billy Ray,” said the spokesperson, “and he thought it was funny.”
Reps for Adkins did not immediately respond to a request for comment
Lil Nas X is having a particularly good week: Heâs on the cover of Time magazine alongside the headline “Itâs His Country,” and the song set the record for most weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 even before it got to its current 19-weeks-straight mark. Its reception in the mainstream country community has been mixed. Fans have largely embraced “Old Town Road,” with younger country fans clearly having a taste for hip-hop sounds. Music Row has cast an indifferent, if not necessarily antagonistic, eye on the songâs success. In preliminary balloting for the upcoming CMA Awards , “Old Town Road” failed to make the second ballot in any division except the “musical event” category, where it remains to be seen whether itâll make the final five when nominations are announced in September
The potential awkwardness of the Lil Nas X/Hank Jr. juxtaposition is heightened by past controversies involving the use of Confederate flag imagery or advocacy by all the performers involved. Shelton defended the “rebel flag flying” in his hit “Kiss My Country Ass,” and Adkins once apologized after wearing a Confederate flag earpiece on a TV appearance, vowing not to do so again. Neither starâs use of the flag compares to that of Williams Jr., whoâs famous for selling flag merch at his shows, and who sang “If the South would have won (the Civil War), we would have it made” in one of his signature hits (long before having his NFL theme song knocked off the air after calling President Obama an America-hating Muslim and comparing him to Hitler). It was kerfuffles like those that led Brad Paisley to address his own past use of the Confederate flag in his song “The Accidental Racist,” which itself became a magnet for controversy
Regardless of whether any such connotations occurred to Shelton or Adkins (or songwriters Thomas Hardy, David Garcia and Brett Tyler), the lyrics are still being widely perceived as, at the very least, a slam against the genre-crossing “Old Town Road.” But Sheltonâs spokesperson insists even that is an overreach for what is intended as a kiddingly affectionate reference, pointing out that the female characters in the song are playing the ubiquitous Lil Nas X tune before opting to replace him with Hank Jr
Popular on Variety